The Black Caucus is going through an identity crisis. In recent weeks, leaders of the caucus found themselves defending the need for their group, composed of 41 House Democrats. It also is in the midst of an uneasy generational shift, as the old lions of the civil rights era begin to give way to a younger generation of black politicians who do not want to be pigeonholed by race.
First, we have discussed the youngsters' concern for being pigeonholed by race.
When I asked Booker if he considered himself a leader of the black community, he seemed to freeze for a moment. “I’m Popeye,” he replied finally. “I am what I am.” He paused again, then tried to explain.
“I don’t want to be pigeonholed,” he said. “I don’t want people to expect me to speak about those issues.” By this, presumably, he meant issues that revolve around race: profiling by police, incarceration rates, flagging urban economies. “I want people to ask me about nonproliferation. I want them to run to me to speak about the situation in the Middle East.” Since the mayor of Newark is rarely called upon to discuss such topics, I got the feeling that Booker does not see himself staying in his current job for anything close to 20 years. “I don’t want to be the person that’s turned to when CNN talks about black leaders,” he said.
Mayor Booker, you ran for the position of New Black Leader of Newark just as surely as the Moses imagery in John McCain's ad harkens back to slave imagery in Southern minds. Your JOB is to speak about those issues. I understand ambition; I know you git in where you fit in. But I also know Mayor of Newark is a stepping stone for you. That this is not the job you want.
It's as bad concern to raise in connection with the CBC, who for the most part are elected by Black folk, as it is for the Mayor of a pretty Black city.
Now, let's talk about the need for the group. The need for the group is tied up in common interests, and the fact that they are elected by Black folk who, in general, cannot fund them the way some other politicians are by their constituencies. I'm pretty comfortable calling the CBC more of a networking organization as a political one.
A number of them have accrued seniority that requires they be given significant power. I mean they aren't going to challenge the status quo beyond insisting more Black folk get into the game, they aren't going to challenge the rationale or goals implied by our national decisions. I think Charlie Rangel has the most juice and he's seriously not a radical. But that all that power is concentrated in the CBC is nervous-making in some circles because it makes the organization a political force for the first time. I think this would have come to pass whoever was elected...you just may not have heard about it.
Finally, yes, "Obama's election was a sign the country [is] moving beyond it's racially troubled past." But it's not a transformation it's a process...one which knuckledraggers who think they don't have to learn because it changed without them doing a damn thing different can inhibit.
Congressional Black Caucus Assesses Its Role Under a Black President
By DAVID M. HERSZENHORN