I'm leading with the last paragraph because, in a nation where +90% of liability settlements lead with a line about how the payment isn't an admission of guilt, this
The district attorney's office in this case wants nothing more than to see this juvenile re-enter society and never cause another problem for herself by following the rules that society puts in place through its various organizations and formats (school, public laws, etc.). It is our position that she's spent more than enough time in TYC - in fact, never had to go there - and that if TYC feels she has learned her lesson, then let her out.
...may be the best it gets.
That's from Regarding the Shaquanda Cotton case, published on the Lamar County & District Attorney website, which I quote no further from because it's a restatement of Judge Superville's self-defense.
I personally think it insufficient. I'd like the child to get some legit therapy, both for her reported ADHD and for the shit she went through for the last year. And I'd like any record sealed. And maybe some help move to Dallas or something.
But I'm a realist. There will be no public admission they mishandled everything. There should be, though...I quote once again from Dallas South Blog, which is written by a resident of Paris, TX. He's presented Top Ten Misperceptions and Miscalculations relating to the Paris Texas Story. Three have bearing on the actual case; the others are things that offend the sensibilities of folks who would never have heard it if they hadn't gotten out of pocket.
10. Paris Independent School District underestimated some in Black Community
The Paris Schools have been accused of racism and bias in a number of specific incidents over the past three or four years. Many of the claims were frivolous and involved problem children whose parents were trying to get over for them.
However there were some disciplinary actions taken against black students that were inappropriate, perpetuated by teachers and administrators that I have known and respected. The district thought that by reassigning those involved the problems, and complaints, would go away. They did not account for the resolve of the parties involved, and hence had no long term strategy. Had the district had better follow through, and protected the students as they did the administrators, they may have been able to avoid some of the backlash.
"The district thought that by reassigning those involved the problems, and complaints, would go away," huh? The Catholic Church tranferring those pedophile priests would make the problems and complaints go away too.
This is what Creola Cotton and her associates were protesting, by the way.
5. The City and School is Faultless
As is the case 99% of the time, Anglo parties wonder where all of these problems are coming from for a city where whites and black get along so well. And I admit white and black do get along O.K. and it's not because black folks roll over. But the majority (for now) in this country has to understand that even though "it wasn't their fault," they are still the beneficiaries 250 years of slavery, and 100 years of Jim Crow Semi-Slavery.
My mother was in the last graduating class of the Black High School in Paris - 1966. This same school system that provided her and her peers with old, worn, written in textbooks is the same system that is charged with educating the grandchildren and great-grand children or those former Gibbons High students. The products the segregated Paris schools are still in leadership, and their children and grandchildren benefit from it whether they know it or not. This is not unique to Paris, Texas. [P6: True.]
1. The 14 year-old was sentenced to 7 years in prison
I can say that I thought this was the punishment handed out by Judge "Chuck" Superville, however I have since found out that the sentence he handed out was one (1) to seven (7) year, and was eligible for release after one year for behavior parameters. And this was juvenile court, not adult court. Still seems like a stiff sentence, though other options were considered.
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Furl
Google
Yahoo
Many years ago I used to
Many years ago I used to work closely with "dependent, neglected and abused" children which is a polite and accurate alternative to calling them "juvenile delinquents". I can't recall any child that I knew or heard about with no previous record who would have been sentenced from one to seven years in a juvenile correction facility for pushing a school teacher or an adult hall monitor.Â
Judge Superville and the District Attorney's office in that county are out of hand. The child should be sent to live out of state if possible. Texas is no place for her to be somebody. Â
I can't imagine having to
I can't imagine having to try and recover from this ordeal at such a tender age. Miss Cotton's road to recover will be long and harsh. Merely releasing her will not be enough. The time she has lost where she should have been in school needs to be addressed. The state should pay in some way to get her back on track.Â
Good news: she's going to be
Good news: she's going to be released Saturday (or later today, if you're on EST). The links to the Paris News article and the Chicago Tribune article are on that entry. :)